Just so's (sic) you know, I was checking out General Petraeus, he has never been in combat, yet he has been awarded a Bronze Star with a "V" device. The "V" device can only be awarded for instances of courage under fire, otherwise it is awarded without the "V". He was however shot by his own man in a live fire exercise at Ft. Campbell and operated on by Dr. Bill Frist in Tennessee.

The relevance here is regarding "Stolen Valor" and character implications. Much ado was made regarding Kerry's decorations and I am not sure how the "Stolen Valor Act of 2005" applies to active duty. The most common decoration for valor in the Army is the Army commendation medal with "V" device, followed by the Bronze Star with "V". Common definitely inferring the enlisted grades, the Bronze W/V practically equaling the valor of officers with the Silver Star. It is not unusal for an executive officer to write up his CO. I admit a certain prejudice against general officers and have directly inquired of General Wesley Clark regarding his Silver Star. It was an embarassing moment for both of us.

Why is it important to expose Petraeus? He is a wannabee and he is willing to lie for ambitious reasons. He is indicative of the majority of the General Officers Corps, petty and self absorbed

Bronze Star Medal

The medal may be awarded for Valor (i.e. courage under fire), in which case it is accompanied with an attached V or it may be awarded for Meritorious Achievement (i.e. doing one's job well) in which case the medal does not have a valor component and does not have an attached V denoting Valor. Most of the bronze stars awarded are for non valor and do not have the V device.

The medal is awarded to a member of the military who, while serving in or with the military of the United States after 6 December 1941, distinguished him or herself by heroic or meritorious achievement or service, not involving participation in aerial flight, while engaged in an action against an enemy of the United States; while engaged in military operations involving conflict with an opposing foreign force; or while serving with friendly foreign forces engaged in an armed conflict against an opposing armed force in which the United States is not a belligerent party.

Awards may be made for acts of heroism, performed under circumstances described above, which are of lesser degree than required for the award of the Silver Star. Awards may also be made to recognize single acts of merit or meritorious service. The required achievement or service while of lesser degree than that required for the award of the Legion of Merit must nevertheless have been meritorious and accomplished with distinction.

To be eligible for the Bronze Star Medal, a military member must be receiving hostile fire/imminent danger pay during the event for which the medal is to be awarded.

 

Source: Wikipedia

 

From Army HRC (need AKO access)

Awards OIF Total

15 Mar 03 – 28 Feb 06
 

Medal of Honor

1

Distinguished Service Cross

2

Silver Star

195

Legion of Merit

22

Distinguished Flying Cross

37

Soldier's Medal

73

Meritorious Service Medal

6,956

Bronze Star Medal for Valor

1,039

Bronze Star Medal svc/ach

36,989

Purple Heart

11,734

Air Medal for Valor

391

Air Medal svc/ach

8,346

ARCOM for valor

2,784

ARCOM svc/ach

101,819

Army Achievement Medal

6,830
 

Combat Infantryman Badge

22,602

Combat Medical Badge

6,437

Combat Action Badge

14,858
 

Grand Total

221,115


OEF
5 Dec 01 – 28 Feb 06
 

Medal of Honor
0
0
0

Distinguished Service Cross

1

Silver Star

45

Legion of Merit

3

Distinguished Flying Cross

55

Soldier's Medal

16

Meritorious Service Medal

772

Bronze Star Medal for Valor

528

Bronze Star Medal svc/ach

10,327

Purple Heart
404


Air Medal for Valor
49

Air Medal sev/ach

2,776

ARCOM for valor

373

ARCOM svc/ach

16,604

Army Achievement Medal

1,782

Combat Infantryman Badge

9,537


Combat Action Badge

2,595
 

Total

47,609